Key points
- 4–20 mA: one value per pair of wires; 'live zero' at 4 mA reveals a broken loop.
- HART: digital data superimposed on 4–20 mA; analog value stays the primary signal.
- Modbus RTU: multi-drop digital bus; many values per device; needs addressing and termination.
- Many Supmea instruments offer two at once, such as 4–20 mA plus RS485.
How each one works
4–20 mA represents 0–100% of range as a current, so cable resistance does not change the reading and a value below 4 mA signals a fault (current loop). HART superimposes a frequency-shift-keyed digital signal on the same loop, maintained by the FieldComm Group. Modbus RTU is a master/slave protocol, typically over two-wire RS-485, where each device has an address (Modbus Organization).
Comparison
| Criterion | 4–20 mA | 4–20 mA + HART | Modbus RTU (RS-485) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Values per device | 1 | 1 analog + several digital | Many |
| Wiring | 1 pair per device | 1 pair per device | 1 bus, daisy-chained |
| Loop-powered 2-wire | Yes | Yes | Usually separate power |
| Diagnostics | Fault current only | Yes | Yes (register map) |
| Speed | Continuous | Digital part slow (~1200 bit/s) | Polling, typically 9600–38400 bit/s |
| Typical use | PLC/DCS inputs, SIS | Process plants, asset management | Skids, CDUs, water SCADA, BMS gateways |
Selection rules
- Safety or interlock signal: 4–20 mA (with HART if you want diagnostics).
- More than about 5 instruments on one skid controller: Modbus RTU reduces wiring and gives totals and alarms.
- Long cable runs in noisy plants: 4–20 mA, shielded twisted pair.
- Need both: many Supmea devices provide 4–20 mA and RS485 together, for example the LDG-SUP-A100 and SUP-TDS210-B.
Related questions
How many devices can share one RS-485 segment?
The RS-485 standard allows 32 unit loads per segment without repeaters; fewer if devices draw more than one unit load.
Does HART affect the 4–20 mA accuracy?
No. The HART signal averages to zero, so the analog value is unaffected.
Sources and further reading
Product specifications quoted here are summarised from Supmea datasheets. Confirm the figures for your exact model before final design.